My family owns two supplement brands, Nutrithority and Alchemy Labs. So when I recommend one of our products, you might wonder about it. Fair enough. Let me address that.
Of course I prefer our brands. I make money when they sell, but that's not the only reason.
My supplement cabinet is full of Nutrithority because I've seen how the sausage gets made. I know the people making the calls, what goes into the products, and some of the shortcuts we've turned down that would have made them cheaper. If I really didn't believe in them, I could easily use another brand and nobody would ever know.
The best example goes back to why we started Nutrithority.
When we launched Nutrithority in 2013, amino spiking (also called protein spiking) was a big problem in the protein industry.
Companies would add cheap free-form amino acids or other nitrogen-heavy ingredients to their protein powders. Protein was usually measured by nitrogen, so those add-ins made a tub look like it had more protein than it really did. It ended up in a lot of lawsuits, like the one in this federal court opinion.
We'd been selling supplements for years, and finding a whey isolate we trusted was frustrating. So we decided to make our own.
We went to a contract manufacturer with simple requirements. We wanted real, 100% whey protein isolate, made with cross-flow microfiltration, with no added amino acids padding the numbers.
When the first samples showed up, I was excited. I tore one open, mixed it up, and took a drink.
Something tasted off. I'd had enough of these products to recognize what I thought was the taste of added amino acids, so I checked the label.
Glutamine. Taurine. Glycine.
There they were. We'd told the manufacturer, specifically, no added amino acids, and the very first samples had them. They got an email.
Back then, zero-carb, zero-fat whey isolates were all the rage. Those zeros looked great on a label, but we were set on cross-flow microfiltered isolate.
Our contract manufacturer told us that with what they offered, we'd have to pick one: 100% real protein with no amino spiking, OR amino spike and get the zero-carb, zero-fat numbers. We picked the protein. I'd rather sell you an actual true isolate protein with a gram of fat or a few carbs than water down the formula just to put two zeros on the front of the tub.
We asked for new samples without the added aminos. The manufacturer wasn't quick about anything, so we waited weeks for the next round. I guess that was an early lesson that making the product we wanted wasn't going to be the cheapest or easiest way to do it.
My younger brother Jared runs Nutrithority day to day and works directly on product development. We talk all the time, and he's regularly bouncing ideas off me.
I give him my two cents, and the big decisions go through Jared, my older brother Jason, my dad, and me. I'm not the one formulating products or managing manufacturing, but I understand the decisions being made, money included.
I know what some of those ingredient and manufacturing choices cost. I also know the cheaper option can look just as good on a label.
So when I see my family pick the more expensive route because it makes a better product, that means something to me. I can't have that kind of confidence in a brand when I can't see the decisions being made.
None of this means Nutrithority is the only brand I trust.
Nutristat is probably my favorite brand I don't own a piece of. Their products are excellent, and our logos look enough alike that customers mix us up now and then. I regularly use their stuff just for a change of pace, whether that's a different take on a formula or new flavors.
I'm also a fan of NOW Foods. I take their magnesium threonate every day, plus different vitamins and other supplements depending on what I need.
Lots of companies make great products. Sometimes another brand has something we don't, or a formula that fits a customer better. And sometimes two products are both good enough that it comes down to price, taste, or what you like.
Because I believe in them. I don't hide that it's ours with my customers. I probably use the phrase 'this is my family's brand' 2-3 times a day.
I've watched my family make choices that cost us money because they made a better product. Seeing that firsthand gives me confidence in what we sell. It doesn't mean our stuff automatically beats everything else on the shelf.
And I'll tell a customer when one of our products isn't right for them. I'd rather point them to something that works for what they need, no matter whose name is on the label.
Like I said in The First Question I Ask Before I Recommend a Supplement, the customer's goal comes first and the product comes second.
Ryan Ragsdale is the CEO of Supplement Giant, a multi-location supplement retailer with stores across Colorado and Kansas. He grew up in the supplement industry and has spent over 30 years around supplements, including the last 18 running Supplement Giant.