Over the past 20-plus years, I've watched pre-workouts go through three distinct eras: the birth of the modern pre-workout, the ultra-concentrated stimulant craze, and the more comprehensive, high-dose formulas we're seeing today.
Pre-workouts existed long before N.O.-Xplode hit the market in 2004, but N.O.-Xplode solidified the modern pre-workout category as we know it. I remember my dad taking the original Ultimate Orange (with ephedrine) before his workouts when I was a kid.
The concept was simple. Instead of buying separate products for energy, creatine, nitric oxide support and other workout-related benefits, you could get them together in one formula.
It was a big development for the industry, and there were good ideas behind a lot of these products. The problem was that consumers had a hard time telling what was in them.
Most products relied heavily on proprietary blends. You might see caffeine, arginine, creatine, various amino acids and a long list of other ingredients, but you couldn't always tell how much of each one you were getting.
That also made it easy for manufacturers to throw in tiny, useless amounts of expensive or popular ingredients just so they could advertise them on the label. It's commonly called pixie dusting. Protein had its own version of this with amino spiking, and my family started Nutrithority to combat it.
Arginine was especially popular during this period, and manufacturers were pushing it hard for nitric oxide production. The formulas were still a long way from the citrulline-heavy products we see today.
Some of the younger guys out there kind of take pre-workouts for granted. But this was revolutionary for the time. Pre-workout was becoming its own major supplement category.
Around 2008, USP Labs introduced Jack3d, and the pre-workout market started moving in a very different direction.
Ultra-concentrated pre-workouts traded large scoops with a variety of ingredients for surprisingly small servings that promised intense effects.
DMAA was the defining ingredient of this period.
I understood the appeal, but I personally hated the stuff. The first several hours after taking a DMAA pre-workout could feel fantastic, even euphoric, and the energy and stimulation were intense. But the crash afterward was miserable and could ruin the rest of my day. That wasn't a tradeoff I was interested in making.
I've always thought of those ultra-concentrated products as being closer to energy drinks than what I wanted from a pre-workout anyway.
Even during the ultra-concentrated craze, the industry didn't abandon comprehensive formulas. Many manufacturers offered both styles. Betancourt, for example, sold Bullnox alongside its DMAA-driven D-Stunner. I definitely gravitated toward Bullnox and Dymatize's Xpand Xtreme Pump.
I loved both of those products. They were more comprehensive formulas, with ingredients meant to support different parts of training, so they didn't lean almost entirely on the stimulant experience. They still used proprietary blends, but you could see things moving in that direction.
Bullnox Androrush was one of the early adopters of citrulline, combining it with arginine. Xpand Xtreme Pump broke its ingredients into smaller proprietary blends, which gave you a better idea of how much of each group you were getting. It had a 5g creatine matrix, a 3.5g arginine blend and a 5g amino acid complex.
They were serving different customer preferences, and let's be honest, if the original Jack3d came back tomorrow, there would be an enormous number of people lining up to buy it.
I personally never believed the hardest-hitting pre-workout was necessarily the best one. At the end of the day, the question is what's going to give you the best workout. Everyone is going to have a different answer to that question. And that's what makes America great.
The next major shift was toward larger, more fully dosed formulas and transparent ingredient labels.
Where customers used to see a wall of proprietary blends, manufacturers now showed exactly how much of each ingredient you were getting, like six grams of citrulline malate, 300 milligrams of caffeine or two grams of beta-alanine. The amounts themselves became selling points.
One of the products I associate with this transition is Pre JYM, introduced by Jim Stoppani in 2013. Pre JYM wasn't necessarily the first product to move in this direction, but it became a well-known example of a different way to market pre-workouts.
Marketing helped create demand for something that I believe improved the category. I saw manufacturers start to push transparency in their marketing, and that gave consumers a reason to care about what was in their supplements and how much of it they were getting.
Manufacturers started competing over how much of the supporting ingredients they could include. Citrulline, beta-alanine, betaine, creatine, nitrates and other ingredients became a bigger part of the formulation conversation.
Companies had more ways to set their formulas apart, so they weren't competing almost entirely over how intense a product felt.
Of the three eras, this one is easily my favorite.
You can find products built around energy, pumps, endurance, focus or some combination. You can compare ingredient amounts, figure out what makes sense for your goals and choose based on that.
That wasn't nearly as easy 20 years ago.
There are still plenty of mediocre products, unnecessary ingredients and impressive-looking labels that don't necessarily mean better results, but I like what manufacturers are competing over today. Many are trying to build more complete formulas that cover different parts of training.
A strong stimulant experience will probably always have its fans, but I think the industry's shift toward more comprehensive formulas has produced better products.
Ryan Ragsdale is the CEO of Supplement Giant, a multi-location supplement retailer with stores across Colorado and Kansas. He grew up in the supplement industry and has spent over 30 years around supplements, including the last 18 running Supplement Giant.